Bitcoin IRA ad showing The Ultimate Guide to Bitcoin IRA Investing, with the line Featured in Forbes and the Bitcoin IRA logo.
Back to case studies
  • Crypto retirement
  • Demand generation

Bitcoin IRA

Building the demand engine behind a new investment category

Alex Wills, Director of Demand Generation at Bitcoin IRA, January 2017 to April 2018 (prior role).

  • $117.9M

    Investment volume

    May to December 2017

  • 2,067

    Unique investors

    May to December 2017

  • $26.7M

    Peak month

    December 2017

  • 4.2×

    Monthly ad spend growth

    $200K to $839K, September 2017 to January 2018

Alex's role: Director of Demand Generation, leading paid media, partners, landing pages, and lead flow. Investment volume is what investors paid, including fees: a company total, not revenue. Excluding orders that may be buybacks, it is $105.9M+.

Overview

Bitcoin IRA let investors hold cryptocurrency inside retirement accounts, at a time when most of them were still learning what Bitcoin was. I built and led its demand generation, first as a consultant and then as Director of Demand Generation from January 2017 to April 2018. From May to December 2017, 2,067 investors placed $117.9M in orders, peaking at $26.7M in December.

Bitcoin IRA was not a Reg CF, Reg A+, or Reg D offering, so this page reports investment volume rather than capital raised. The marketing problem is one a raise shares: an unfamiliar financial product, investors who need education before they act, and a sales team that depends on the quality of its leads.

Bar chart of Bitcoin IRA investment volume by month in 2017: May $6.1M, Jun $12.6M, Jul $5.3M, Aug $9.5M, Sep $18.3M, Oct $14.4M, Nov $25.0M, Dec $26.7M. $0 $10M $20M $30M May 2017: $6.1M$6.1MMay Jun 2017: $12.6MJun Jul 2017: $5.3MJul Aug 2017: $9.5MAug Sep 2017: $18.3M$18.3MSep Oct 2017: $14.4MOct Nov 2017: $25.0MNov Dec 2017: $26.7M$26.7MDec
Investment volume by order date, 2017, including fees and any possible buybacks: May $6.1M, June $12.6M, July $5.3M, August $9.5M, September $18.3M, October $14.4M, November $25.0M, December $26.7M. Bitcoin's price rose sharply over the same months.

The challenge

A new category with no playbook

Bitcoin IRA had a first-mover product, but the market was early. Mainstream retirement investors needed education, reassurance, and repeated exposure before they would consider moving retirement funds into digital assets. Clicks alone would not do it: investors had to understand the product, trust the company, and believe crypto could belong in a retirement strategy.

The company also needed enough qualified leads to feed a growing sales team, without spend outrunning what that team could call, qualify, and close.

Goals and scope

Goals

  • Capture investors already searching for Bitcoin and retirement investing
  • Teach a broader personal finance audience that crypto could be held in a retirement account
  • Build credibility for a new kind of financial product
  • Give a growing sales team enough qualified leads
  • Scale paid media while tracking results to funded accounts

What I owned

  • Demand generation
  • Paid media
  • Landing pages
  • Affiliate and publisher partners
  • Investor messaging
  • Lead scoring and allocation
  • Channel reporting

Teams I coordinated

  • Sales leadership
  • Closing agents
  • Affiliates and publishers

The playbook

The demand engine I built

  1. Repositioned the brand and website for a mainstream audience

    I started as a consultant on brand, the website, and paid media. The redesign made the product easier to understand for a mainstream retirement audience and supported the initial market launch. As channel performance accelerated, the work grew into full-time ownership of lead generation in January 2017.

  2. Captured high-intent search demand

    I targeted searches around Bitcoin IRAs, crypto retirement, and 401(k) rollovers, refined negative keyword lists, and connected Search, Display, YouTube, and Gmail campaigns. Custom tracking tied paid media to Salesforce, so campaigns were judged on funded retirement accounts rather than clicks. Google Search ($17.1M) and Google Display ($16.3M) were the two largest tagged sources of investment volume from May to December 2017.

    Forbes's coverage of Bitcoin IRA credited its Google advertising. See Press.

    Google Ads preview of a Bitcoin IRA display ad headed Rollover Your IRA, offering a free eBook, The Ultimate Guide to Bitcoin IRA Investing.
    A Google display ad from May 2017. Claims in the ad were Bitcoin IRA's own at the time.
  3. Tested channels widely and moved budget to what funded

    Beyond Google, I ran Bing, Yahoo Gemini, Facebook, Twitter, Quora, native placements, retargeting, ad networks, direct publisher deals, and a radio test, reaching both mainstream finance and crypto-native audiences. Performance by channel, platform, and source showed where funded accounts came from, and budget moved there.

    Monthly ad spend grew from $200K in September 2017 to a peak of $839K in January 2018, 4.2 times in four months. Actual ad spend from July 2017 to May 2018 was $5.26M.

  4. Launched the affiliate and partner program

    I launched the affiliate marketing department and built relationships across 100+ media, influencer, crypto, and financial-services sources, including direct publisher deals with CoinDesk and Investing.com. Partners gave an unfamiliar product reach and credibility. The channel brought in $4.07M in verified investment volume from May to December 2017, then $2.63M in February 2018 alone, 23% of that month's purchases.

  5. Built and tested the landing pages

    I created landing pages for crypto retirement investors and refined them with heatmaps, click tracking, page testing, and funnel analysis. The messaging mattered as much as the layout: the product had to make sense to a mainstream audience, and each page change was tied back to lead volume and sales capacity.

  6. Worked the sales floor and set lead allocation

    I sat with the sales team to see whether new leads were contactable, qualified, and ready for an advisor conversation, then used that feedback to change campaigns and follow-up. I also built a lead-scoring and allocation engine and set the allocation myself, matching leads to each person's capacity and conversion performance instead of routing every inquiry equally. That lead flow supported 23 to 29 closing agents.

Press

Forbes on Bitcoin IRA

First-mover advantage and aggressive Google advertising campaigns have allowed them to build the largest presence in the crypto-asset IRA space, with close to 4,000 customers and $105 million in inflows since they began accepting funds in June 2016.

Jeff Kauflin, Forbes The Hail Mary Retirement Plan: Bitcoin IRA, February 7, 2018

About Bitcoin IRA, where Alex led demand generation efforts.

Key moves

What changed

  1. A brand and website rebuilt for a mainstream retirement audience
  2. Search, display, and retargeting tracked through Salesforce to funded accounts
  3. Budget moved by channel, platform, and source as funded accounts came in
  4. An affiliate program across 100+ media, influencer, crypto, and financial-services sources
  5. Landing pages refined with heatmaps, click tracking, and testing
  6. Lead allocation matched to each closer's capacity and performance

Results

The numbers

Each figure comes from my reconciliation of Bitcoin IRA's order data, CRM lead export, and marketing budget.

  • $34 to $43

    Investment volume per $1 of ad spend

    August to December 2017, blended across all sources

  • 26%

    Investors who reinvested

    May to December 2017, bringing in 48% of volume

  • $11.35M

    New and reload purchases in one month

    February 2018, a falling market, 15.3× ad spend

  • $4.07M

    Partner channel investment volume

    May to December 2017

  • 1.9%

    Unique leads who became investors

    80,165 leads, 1,511 investors, July 2016 to November 2017

  • 23 to 29

    Closing agents supported

    2017 through February 2018

Results in detail

What the numbers mean

The $117.9M is gross order volume from May to December 2017: what investors paid, including Bitcoin IRA's fees. It is not revenue. Of those orders, 268 worth $11.95M carried a fee of 5% or less, the same flat fee charged on buybacks in February 2018, so the conservative purchase figure is $105.9M+.

Bitcoin's price rose from about $4K to about $19K over the same period, and September to December made up 72% of the eight-month total. The market helped, and this page does not separate its effect from the marketing's.

The $34 to $43 per $1 of ad spend is blended: all sales divided by all ad spend. Spend is recorded when it was paid, not when the ads ran, so the figure is a range. 37% of the volume has no source tag, so each channel's figure understates its real contribution.

February 2018 was a falling market. Investors made $11.35M in new and reload purchases against $744K in ad spend. A further $9.54M in buybacks that month is counted separately.

Across my full tenure (January 2017 to April 2018), Bitcoin IRA took in at least $117M in investor purchases from 2,300+ investors, counting only the months with order data (May to December 2017 and February 2018, buybacks excluded). No order data exists for January to April 2017 or January, March and April 2018, so this is a floor, not a total. The paid media and partner channels I ran were directly tagged to $43.5M from 770 investors from May to December 2017; 37% of volume had no source tag.

Timeline

From consultant to Director of Demand Generation

  1. About October 2016

    I began consulting on the brand, website, and paid media.

  2. January 2017

    I joined full-time and took over lead generation.

  3. May to December 2017

    2,067 investors placed $117.9M in orders.

  4. December 2017

    The peak month: $26.7M in investment volume.

  5. January 2018

    Monthly ad spend peaked at $839K, up from $200K in September.

  6. February 2018

    $11.35M in new and reload purchases in a falling market.

  7. April 2018

    My role as Director of Demand Generation ended.

Key learnings

Learning Experiences

  1. Education is part of acquisition. Investors have to understand an unfamiliar product and trust the company before an ad can do its job.
  2. Measure to funded accounts, not leads. Budget should follow what funds.
  3. Partners lend credibility where trust is the hurdle. Publishers and influencers reached investors that paid search could not.
  4. Marketing and sales run on the same lead flow. Time on the sales floor changed what I bought and who received which leads.

FAQ

Questions about this case study

Why does this page say investment volume instead of capital raised?

Bitcoin IRA was not a Reg CF, Reg A+, or Reg D offering. Investors bought cryptocurrency through retirement accounts, so the figures are order volume: what they paid, including fees.

How much of the $117.9M came from marketing?

The figures do not say. The $117.9M is a company total, and 37% of it has no source tag. Where the page names a channel, the figure is what that channel's tagged orders brought in.

What is a buyback?

An investor selling coins back. Buybacks are not purchases, so they are kept apart where the data labels them, as in February 2018. The 2017 order file has no such label, which is why the page gives $105.9M+ as the conservative figure beside the $117.9M gross.

Can RaiseFM do this work on my raise?

RaiseFM works on the same parts of a raise: positioning, investor education, paid media, partners, landing pages, and follow-up with the people who call or invest. The rules depend on your offering path, and your counsel confirms what applies. A past result is not a promise of funding.

Next step

The only fundraising consultant with direct platform and issuer experience. Work with Alex.

Share where the raise stands, the offering path, your timing, and the main challenge. Alex reviews every inquiry personally.

  1. You send a short inquiry: a few short questions about the raise, then how to reach you.
  2. We reply within one business day, whether or not the work is a fit.
  3. If it's a fit, you book a 30-minute first conversation from the link in that reply.

Tell us about your raise.

A few questions to help us understand your plans and where we can help.